The Ethics of Entrepreneurship: A Tale from the Junior Achievement Experience
As professionals, we often find ourselves navigating the murky waters of ethical conduct, particularly when mentoring the next generation of business leaders. A recent experience mentoring a high school Junior Achievement team forced me to confront the complexities of integrity in business, mixed with a bit of humor.
Our group, comprised of 2nd and 3rd-year associates, joined forces to guide students in creating and running a small business for several months. The entrepreneurial challenge at hand? Sell fruit baskets. The students would purchase bulk fruit, assemble the baskets, and deliver them to homes in the community.
While the initiative aimed to teach important business concepts, it came with rules that, in practice, posed significant challenges. Notably, Junior Achievement mandated that our business could not take on any debt. While the intention behind this policy was well-placed—protecting both the organization and its young entrepreneurs—it presented a practical dilemma: how could we acquire fruit without the necessary funds if we couldn’t create any liabilities?
In search of a solution, we devised a strategy that revolved around prepayments. Customers were required to pay in advance for their fruit baskets, giving us the funds we needed to source our materials. From a business standpoint, this method was undeniably effective.
However, this is where the story takes a turn toward the ethically dubious. As part of our mentorship, we were tasked with creating weekly financial reports for submission to the Junior Achievement office. The issue? If we accurately recorded the cash collections and the deferred revenue, the organization would likely raise concerns.
What began as a pragmatic workaround quickly morphed into an unintended ethical quandary. To manage the situation, we maintained two sets of financial records. One was our “actual” Bookkeeping, which tracked all customer payments and delivery obligations, while the other was a sanitized version destined for the eyes of the Junior Achievement office.
As the weeks progressed, we unwittingly involved the students in this dual ledger system. The realization that we were operating with two distinct sets of books dawned on us during a casual team discussion. Yet, with only a few weeks remaining in the project and the current method yielding favorable results, we continued along this slippery slope.
This experience serves as a humorous yet cautionary tale about the complexities of ethics in business, especially when teaching young minds. It highlights the need for transparency, accountability, and the importance of modeling integrity in all aspects of our professional lives. In our
No responses yet