A Lesson in Ethics: The Double-Booked Business Experience
Reflecting on my career, I’ve encountered numerous situations that tested my ethical boundaries. One particularly amusing incident stems from my involvement with a Junior Achievement team, composed of high school students eager to learn about the business world. As mentors, a group of second- and third-year associates volunteered our time to guide these aspiring entrepreneurs through the complexities of setting up a small business over the course of a few months.
Our team decided to sell fruit baskets—an idea that seemed straightforward enough. The plan was to purchase bulk fruit and baskets, assemble the products, and deliver them within our local community. However, Junior Achievement’s stringent regulations presented an unusual hitch: the business was prohibited from incurring any debt. While this rule was designed to protect the integrity of the program, in practice, it became a challenging obstacle to navigate.
The crux of the issue was clear: How could we acquire fruit without incurring liabilities? We couldn’t, so we devised a workaround. We encouraged customers to prepay for their fruit baskets. By collecting funds when orders were placed, we cleverly sidestepped the debt dilemma and ensured the business could operate smoothly. On the surface, everything seemed to be functioning well.
Here’s where the plot thickens. In order to keep track of our finances, we were tasked with creating weekly financial reports for submission to the Junior Achievement office. But here’s the snag: if we accurately reported our cash collections and deferred revenue, we would raise eyebrows and potentially draw ire from the organization. We had to maintain records detailing who had paid us and whom we owed fruit baskets to, but we couldn’t report everything as it truly was.
In an unanticipated turn of events, we found ourselves maintaining two sets of books. The first was our “real” ledger, which recorded the actual transactions, while the second was a sanitized version that we submitted to the regional office—the version subject to scrutiny. The students we were mentoring, blissfully unaware of the ethical implications, were involved in this dual Accounting practice.
After several weeks of this unusual system, it dawned on us during a casual conversation: “Are we seriously keeping two sets of books?” At that moment, rather than correct our course, we decided to ride out the remaining weeks of the project as it was. After all, we were close to completion, and it appeared that our dual Accounting had successd.
This experience highlighted an unexpected reality: sometimes, the
No responses yet