Should I Transition from Xero to QuickBooks Online? A Decision for My IT Business

As the owner of an IT services company who manages all the Accounting myself, I’m exploring the possibility of transitioning from Xero to QuickBooks Online (QBO). Currently, I’m on my own without the assistance of a bookkeeper, but my expertise in enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems has given me a solid foundation in business software integrations. Over time, I’ve created elaborate connections between our project management tools and both Xero and our payroll service, Employment Hero.

Why I’m Considering a Switch

While Xero has served us reasonably well, there are certain limitations that I’m finding increasingly difficult to overlook:

Project and Transaction Tracking: Xero lacks detailed project codes at the transaction level, offering only basic tracking codes that fall short when you need comprehensive project tracking.
Missing Customization and Visibility: The absence of custom fields and a clear overview of transaction journaling upon creation is a significant drawback.
Time-Consuming Processes: Some tasks take longer than necessary. For instance, verifying that a customer has paid an invoice before approving a bill lacks a straightforward solution.
Handling Overpayments: Xero doesn’t allow seamless management of overpayments by allocating them to future invoices.
Sales and Inventory Limitations: Features like sales orders and goods receipts are noticeably absent from Xero.

Despite these issues, Xero does excel in certain areas, such as its intuitive banking functions (excluding overpayments) and the straightforward nature of creating quotes and invoices. Plus, the aesthetic of the invoices we send is quite pleasing.

QuickBooks Online: A Viable Alternative?

With a competitive pricing structure, QuickBooks Online Advanced has caught my attention with its stellar project Accounting capabilities, which could dramatically improve our operations. However, the software isn’t without its flaws:

Interface and Functionality Issues: Some screens do not resize properly, and while the banking feature works, it’s not quite as seamless as Xero’s. Plus, the invoice design lacks the polish that Xero offers.
Reliability Concerns: Testing has left me feeling a bit anxious regarding QBO’s reliability, compounded by concerning support reviews from other users.

Weighing My Options

The dilemma I’m facing is whether making the switch will ultimately benefit my business or lead to unforeseen headaches. Despite QuickBooks Online offering advanced project Accounting capabilities, reliability and customer support are crucial aspects that

Key Considerations for Making the Move

Project Accounting Features: You’ve mentioned QBO offers robust project Accounting capabilities. This could indeed be a game-changer for your business, especially if detailed project tracking is critical. QBO allows for project-level tracking, budgeting, and time tracking, beyond the scope of Xero’s tracking codes. This might resolve your requirement for detailed project codes and project visibility.

Customizability and User Experience: Both Xero and QBO have their strengths and weaknesses in terms of user interface. While QBO might lack some of the visual appeal of Xero’s invoices, it’s worth exploring the customization options available in QBO. You can modify invoice templates in QBO to better suit your branding and needs. However, be aware of the potential interface issues you mentioned, and consider whether they affect your daily usage significantly.

Integration Capabilities: Since you’ve built a lot of integrations, consider how your existing systems will integrate with QBO. QBO has a comprehensive API and a wide range of integrations available in its App Store. However, the transition will require effort to rebuild or adjust your existing integrations, something you’d need to plan and budget for.

Handling Payments and Transactions: Your concerns around payment management, such as verifying payments before approving bills, are valid. QBO provides a more visible overview of transactions, and its recent features around receivables could potentially address overpayment management better than Xero. It might be worth testing these features to see if they meet your requirements.

Reliability and Customer Support: Reliability and support are crucial, especially if you’re managing accounts without a dedicated bookkeeper. It’s concerning you’ve read reports about poor support. Consider reaching out to Intuit or a trusted QuickBooks consultant to understand the real-time support landscape better. Community forums and reviews can sometimes paint a skewed picture, but speaking directly with users or support could provide a clearer view. Additionally, keep in mind that sometimes, the quality of support you receive can depend on the complexity of your issues and how clearly they are communicated.

One response

APAdmin

3 March 2025 at 9:05 AM
Transitioning from Xero to QuickBooks Online (QBO) is a significant decision, especially for someone deeply embedded in the integration between their current systems—like Project Management and Payroll—with their Accounting Software. Given your IT background and experience with ERP systems, you’re rightly focused on how each platform can meet your needs in terms of features and integrations.

Key Considerations for Making the Move
1. Project Accounting Features: You’ve mentioned QBO offers robust project Accounting capabilities. This could indeed be a game-changer for your business, especially if detailed project tracking is critical. QBO allows for project-level tracking, budgeting, and time tracking, beyond the scope of Xero’s tracking codes. This might resolve your requirement for detailed project codes and project visibility.
2. Customizability and User Experience: Both Xero and QBO have their strengths and weaknesses in terms of user interface. While QBO might lack some of the visual appeal of Xero’s invoices, it’s worth exploring the customization options available in QBO. You can modify invoice templates in QBO to better suit your branding and needs. However, be aware of the potential interface issues you mentioned, and consider whether they affect your daily usage significantly.
3. Integration Capabilities: Since you’ve built a lot of integrations, consider how your existing systems will integrate with QBO. QBO has a comprehensive API and a wide range of integrations available in its App Store. However, the transition will require effort to rebuild or adjust your existing integrations, something you’d need to plan and budget for.
4. Handling Payments and Transactions: Your concerns around payment management, such as verifying payments before approving bills, are valid. QBO provides a more visible overview of transactions, and its recent features around receivables could potentially address overpayment management better than Xero. It might be worth testing these features to see if they meet your requirements.
5. Reliability and Customer Support: Reliability and support are crucial, especially if you’re managing accounts without a dedicated bookkeeper. It’s concerning you’ve read reports about poor support. Consider reaching out to Intuit or a trusted QuickBooks consultant to understand the real-time support landscape better. Community forums and reviews can sometimes paint a skewed picture, but speaking directly with users or support could provide a clearer view. Additionally, keep in mind that sometimes, the quality of support you receive can depend on the complexity of your issues and how clearly they are communicated.
6.
Log in to Reply

Thinking of moving to Quickbooks Online (QBO) from Xero – will I regret it?

Latest Comments