If Shubham Keshwani is really as bad as people say, then why is he producing so many AIRs? I often hear comments like, “He just parrots from his notes, lacks conceptual clarity, and makes everything annoying. You’ll dread Audit!”
On the other hand, you can’t mention Keshwani without someone bringing up Neeraj. But then there’s the crowd that claims, “Rishabh Jain is the GOAT. There’s no one better than him!”
This pretty much sums up the feedback on various instructors. I watch RJ, and I think he’s good, but I don’t really get why he has “God” status. If Keshwani is so ineffective, how does he still help students achieve top ranks? Many of them are getting 90s and 80s in Audits! It’s not like these rankers are super geniuses; they’re just regular students studying alongside us, not born with special skills. So why is Keshwani so highly recommended? Is it a problem with us as students? Even if we accept that 40% is the faculty’s contribution, that still counts.
Everyone emphasizes “Demo,” but let’s be real—demos only show part of the picture: how do classes and note quality hold up later? What about doubt resolution and syllabus coverage? In the end, everyone seems great in a demo.
RJ has a higher fee, and I’m not keen on paying ₹3,000-₹4,000 extra when other instructors charge less—both Keshwani and Arora have batches priced under ₹9,000.
I’m not here to criticize anyone personally, but I need an honest opinion: is Keshwani really that lacking in conceptual clarity? What about his notebooks or question banks? No one seems to back their claims against him; it’s mostly just “He’s a parrot.”
There are polarized opinions out there. Can anyone share a more balanced perspective on his lectures, question banks, notes, and overall effectiveness?
I appreciate your input in advance. I just want to decide between Keshwani and Neeraj; please, no recommendations for RJ since my budget is tight.
Additionally, if I go with Neeraj, should I consider buying Keshwani’s notes as well?
One response
It seems like you’re really weighing your options carefully, and that’s a wise approach. When it comes to choosing between Shubham Keshwani (SK) and Néeraj Arora (NA), here’s a balanced perspective based on what you’ve outlined and typical experiences students have:
Teaching Style: SK is often criticized for his methodology, and many students feel he leans heavily on rote memorization. However, producing AIRs (All India Rankers) can sometimes be attributed to the effectiveness of his exam strategy and question bank rather than pure teaching clarity. Students who excel might find ways to adapt his style to enhance their understanding.
Conceptual Clarity: The opinion on SK’s conceptual clarity is indeed polarized. While some say he lacks depth, others argue that if his teaching resonates with certain students, they might find ways to grasp the concepts, even if it feels like techniques rather than thorough understanding.
Materials: If you’re considering his notes and question banks (QB), you might find that they cater to passing the exam effectively, even if they don’t provide the depth some students seek. Sometimes, a solid QB can be very helpful in revision and practice, which could boost your performance.
Cost vs. Value: You mentioned budget constraints, which is a big factor. If you’re considering both SK and NA’s offerings within your budget, look for any student reviews on how their materials compare. Sometimes, class experience can vary widely even within the same faculty.
Supplementation: If you decide on NA but are curious about SK’s materials, purchasing his notes could provide you with an additional perspective and practice problems. Different approaches can sometimes complement each other well.
Community Feedback: Since you mentioned that many people lean toward strong opinions, try to find some neutral forums where students share their experiences openly, not just the extremes of adoration or disdain. That middle ground can often give you clearer insights.
In conclusion, each faculty member has their strengths and weaknesses, and personal learning styles play a huge role in finding the right fit. Whichever teacher you choose, focus on how you can supplement your learning for the best outcome. Good luck!