Navigating Payroll Challenges After an Employee’s Passing: A Guide to Resolving W2 Amendments

When faced with the loss of an employee, the implications on payroll and tax documentation can be complex and challenging, especially when the passing occurs close to the end of the year. This was the situation for a business recently grappling with the aftermath of an owner’s death in December 2023, which brought to light some unintended consequences for payroll processing and subsequent tax filings.

The Situation at Hand

Following the unfortunate demise of a key employee, a paycheck was still issued after their passing, which included deductions for a 401(k) loan payment and other regular withholdings. The payroll company subsequently generated a W-2 form for January 2024—a practice that is not permitted for deceased individuals. This oversight has prompted a need for action to rectify the financial records.

Request for W2 Amendment: The Ripple Effect

Since I was not part of the organization during the initial occurrences, I had to navigate the resolution of this tax anomaly while assisting the estate with the final tax filings for the deceased. This involved requesting an amendment to the W-2 and issuing a 1099 instead, which seemed like the appropriate course of action. However, the W-2 amendment led to a journal entry from the payroll service that resulted in a negative balance in the loan and withholding liability accounts.

Understanding the Legal and Financial Implications

Typically, if a W-2 is amended in a more timely fashion, the business can reimburse any withheld amounts to the deceased’s estate. However, in this case, significant elapsed time led to the estate transferring funds from the employee’s 401(k), simultaneously moving loan payments and withholdings as well. This situation creates a dilemma as we seek to resolve the negative liabilities that have emerged.

Steps for Resolution

To rectify these pressing payroll issues, the question arises: what is the best course of action? Here are some potential steps:

1. Journal Entry Adjustments: One straightforward approach could be to amend the journal entries, moving the negative amounts from payroll liabilities to payroll expenses. This action might alleviate the immediate Accounting discrepancies on the balance sheet.

2. Impact on Financial Statements: While clearing out the negative liabilities can streamline your books, it’s crucial to consider the broader implications on your financial statements. Transitioning amounts from liabilities to expenses will affect your net income for that Accounting period and, ultimately, impact the profitability reports.

3