Job Offer Withdrawn: A Strange Experience

My Experience

I recently applied for a job that I was clearly overqualified for, after leaving a very toxic workplace. Currently, I’m working part-time remotely as a bookkeeper for a consulting company, but the hours aren’t meeting my needs—I’m maxing out at about 8 hours a week, although the job was advertised as offering anywhere from 8 to 20+ hours weekly.

I decided to apply for a Receptionist/Bookkeeper position at a small Accounting firm. I went through a phone interview followed by an in-person interview with two individuals: the current owner, an older gentleman, and a younger partner who is in the process of buying the firm. They seemed quite impressed with my qualifications. However, the younger partner was particularly focused on the closure dates of my childcare facility, which includes major holidays plus a couple more that could be covered by paid time off (PTO).

Towards the end of the interview, they asked if I had any questions. I inquired if my appearance—specifically, a small blue strip in my hair and a delicate septum ring—would be an issue. Surprisingly, they said it was and appreciated my bringing it up, since it was a significant concern for them. The younger partner pointed at my resume with a vague gesture, suggesting that my professional experience didn’t match my personal appearance, even though I was dressed in appropriate office attire. Interestingly, they also mentioned that due to my overqualification, they might eventually move me to the back office and hire a new receptionist.

An hour after I left, the younger partner called to offer me the position. I requested a few days to consider, as I was evaluating another offer. He agreed and said I had until Tuesday to make my decision.

Just three hours later, the older partner called me back, expressing regrets but informing me that they were rescinding the offer because I had another offer on the table.

Final Thoughts

The whole experience struck me as highly unprofessional. They initially stressed about my appearance but waited for me to bring it up. Additionally, they made me an offer only to retract it within hours because I wanted time to consider. I’ve never encountered such an odd interaction with a company before.

I’m sorry to hear about your experience; it certainly sounds confusing and frustrating. Let’s break down what happened and consider some steps you might take:

Breakdown of the Situation:

Application and Interview Process:
Position: You applied for a Receptionist/Bookkeeper role, despite being overqualified. This is not uncommon, especially if you’re looking for stability or a change in work environment.
Interview: It sounds like the interviews themselves went well initially, with both parties impressed by your experience. However, the younger partner had reservations about your appearance and daycare closures, which influenced their decision-making process.
Appearance Concerns:
Hair and Jewelry: While societal norms are shifting towards greater acceptance of personal expression through hair color and piercings, some traditional workplaces may still hold conservative views. It seems like the firm fits this mold, at least from the younger partner’s perspective.
Professional Image vs. Personal Expression: It’s worth acknowledging that appearance often unjustly influences professional settings. The comment about your professional appearance on paper versus in person is a reflection of potential biases.
The Job Offer and Rescinding:
Offer Made: The younger partner extended the offer after apparently resolving any concerns about your qualifications or appearance.
Offer Rescinded: The older partner withdrew the offer upon learning you were considering another opportunity, which indeed seems unprofessional or hasty. Employers typically expect candidates to evaluate their options.

Why This Happened:

Company Dynamics: The different attitudes of the younger and older partners suggest potential internal misalignment or communication issues within the company.
Perception of Commitment: They may have wanted a quick commitment and misinterpreted your desire to consider your options as a lack of interest.
Potential Red Flags: Rescinding an offer because you need time to consider it can indicate rigidity and possible control issues within the firm.

What You Can Do:

Reflect on the Interview Process:
Consider whether this experience aligns with the work environment you want. If the appearance of professionalism is rigid and not openly discussed, it could lead to larger cultural issues.
Evaluate Other Offers:
Reflect on the other opportunity you mentioned. Ensure it aligns better with your professional goals and values.
Leverage the Learning:
Use this experience to

One response

APAdmin

26 February 2025 at 2:31 PM
I’m sorry to hear about your experience; it certainly sounds confusing and frustrating. Let’s break down what happened and consider some steps you might take:

Breakdown of the Situation:
1. Application and Interview Process:
2. Position: You applied for a Receptionist/Bookkeeper role, despite being overqualified. This is not uncommon, especially if you’re looking for stability or a change in work environment.
3. Interview: It sounds like the interviews themselves went well initially, with both parties impressed by your experience. However, the younger partner had reservations about your appearance and daycare closures, which influenced their decision-making process.
4. Appearance Concerns:
5. Hair and Jewelry: While societal norms are shifting towards greater acceptance of personal expression through hair color and piercings, some traditional workplaces may still hold conservative views. It seems like the firm fits this mold, at least from the younger partner’s perspective.
6. Professional Image vs. Personal Expression: It’s worth acknowledging that appearance often unjustly influences professional settings. The comment about your professional appearance on paper versus in person is a reflection of potential biases.
7. The Job Offer and Rescinding:
8. Offer Made: The younger partner extended the offer after apparently resolving any concerns about your qualifications or appearance.
9. Offer Rescinded: The older partner withdrew the offer upon learning you were considering another opportunity, which indeed seems unprofessional or hasty. Employers typically expect candidates to evaluate their options.
Why This Happened:
- Company Dynamics: The different attitudes of the younger and older partners suggest potential internal misalignment or communication issues within the company.
- Perception of Commitment: They may have wanted a quick commitment and misinterpreted your desire to consider your options as a lack of interest.
- Potential Red Flags: Rescinding an offer because you need time to consider it can indicate rigidity and possible control issues within the firm.
What You Can Do:
1. Reflect on the Interview Process:
2. Consider whether this experience aligns with the work environment you want. If the appearance of professionalism is rigid and not openly discussed, it could lead to larger cultural issues.
3. Evaluate Other Offers:
4. Reflect on the other opportunity you mentioned. Ensure it aligns better with your professional goals and values.
5. Leverage the Learning:
6. Use this experience to
Log in to Reply

Job offer, then rescinded?

Latest Comments