Navigating Client Co-Mingling Issues in QuickBooks: A Case Study

Recently, I was approached by a friend whose client was seeking assistance with transitioning to QuickBooks after her long-time bookkeeper retired. Although I had limited experience with the software, I saw it as an opportunity to learn and engaged in an interview for the position—ultimately landing the role. However, I quickly found myself facing a challenging situation.

The client, who we’ll refer to as Liz, had managed her records manually for over a decade. During this time, a significant issue emerged: the co-mingling of personal and business expenses. As I began to input transactions into QuickBooks, it became clear that Liz was purchasing substantial personal items through her business account, including mortgage payments, utility bills, retirement contributions, gym memberships, and even cable services.

For context, here are some of the transactions I encountered in a typical month for Liz’s landscaping business:

| Vendor | Amount |
|—————————|———-|
| Bob’s Pest Control | $1,000 |
| Jill’s Fertilizing | $600 |
| Insurance Company | $3,000 |
| Ed’s Nursery | $2,000 |
| Chase Bank (Mortgage) | $3,500 |
| Comcast | $200 |
| AT&T | $200 |
| SIMPLE IRA | $4,000 |

The legitimate business expenses included payments to pest control, fertilizers, and nurseries. However, the mortgage and utility payments raised significant red flags. I learned that even the SIMPLE IRA contribution was a personal one made from the business account, which compounded my concern about proper Accounting practices.

Confronting the retiring bookkeeper about these personal expenses led to frustration and confusion. The long-standing practice of hand-writing all transactions and then handing them off to an accountant for reconciliation left little room for critical financial oversight.

Now, my dilemma is clear: how should I address these co-mingling issues in QuickBooks? While it seems straightforward to consider these expenses as “Owner Draws,” I am aware that simply categorizing them may not resolve the underlying problem that Liz and her business face. If I push for her to segregate her expenses, will it lead to further resistance or confusion?

Am I overreacting, or is this a legitimate concern? This scenario raises an essential question regarding best practices in maintaining clear financial records.

Solutions